Download PDF The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past

Download PDF The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past

This is exactly what you should do in needing what exactly we offer. This is not nonsense, this is something to create much better principle. Generally, book will not always influent someone to act and assume far better. It will depend upon how the people will stare and also think of the lesson offered by the book. However, when you have actually handled reviewing the book arranged, the The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past will certainly have regardless of to need.

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past

Download PDF The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past

There are many suggestions that people offer to boost the life quality, regarding everything. Here, we likewise will provide you an extremely simple tip to life better. Checking out The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past is our suggestion. Please ask why we recommend this book to review. Many people aim to make themselves to be rich, but at some point they forget about an extremely basic point. Reading is in fact an easy point, yet several slouch to do it. It's sort of dull activity and waste the time.

If you desire actually obtain the book The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past to refer now, you should follow this page consistently. Why? Remember that you require the The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past source that will provide you appropriate assumption, do not you? By visiting this web site, you have begun to make new deal to constantly be up-to-date. It is the first thing you can start to obtain all profit from being in a site with this The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past and various other collections.

What connection to the reading book activity is from guide, you can see and also recognize just how the guideline of this life. You will see just how the others will gaze to others. As well as will certainly see how the literary works is developed for some enjoyable definition. The Landscape Of History: How Historians Map The Past is one of the works by a person that has such sensation. Based on some truths, it will ensure you to open your mind and also believe together about this topic. This book look will help you making better principle of reasoning.

When you have reviewed it a lot more web pages, you will know a growing number of once again. Furthermore when you have reviewed all finished. That's your time to always keep in mind and also do what the lesson as well as experience of this book supplied to you. By this problem, you need to understand that every publication ahs different means to present the impact to any visitors. Yet they will be and also need to be. This is what the DDD always offers you lesson concerning it.

Review

"Will... never allow either the reader of history or the writer of it to think about the past in quite the same way as before."--The New York Times"A masterful statement on the historical method.... Gaddis' characterization of the social sciences will surely spark debate even as it illuminates important intellectual connections between the disciplines. Delightfully readable, the book is a grand celebration of the pursuit of knowledge."--Foreign Affairs"A bold and challenging book, unafraid of inviting controversy. It provides a strong statement for our time of both the limits and the value of the historical enterprise."--The New York Times Book Review"A real tour de force: a delight to read, and a light-hearted celebration of the odd, 'fractal' patterns that intellectual and other forms of human and natural history exhibit."--William H. McNeill"Turns the old argument over science and history upside down."--The Washington Post Book World"Never before have I come across a book that so illuminated the craft of the historian."--Michael Pakenham, The Baltimore Sun"This is another of those books that rewards the effort it requires. Besides providing invaluable insights into how the historian goes about his business, it teaches--like all really good books--of life beyond its boundaries."--Colin Walters, Washington Times

Read more

About the Author

John Lewis Gaddis is the Robert A. Lovett Professor of Military and Naval History at Yale University. A leading authority on Cold War history, his books include We Now Know, The Long Peace, and Strategies of Containment. He lives in New Haven, Connecticut.

Read more

Product details

Paperback: 208 pages

Publisher: Oxford University Press; 1 edition (April 8, 2004)

Language: English

ISBN-10: 0195171578

ISBN-13: 978-0195171570

Product Dimensions:

7.8 x 0.3 x 5.3 inches

Shipping Weight: 10.7 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)

Average Customer Review:

4.0 out of 5 stars

52 customer reviews

Amazon Best Sellers Rank:

#49,187 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

This book is packed! Being a beginner to this type of historical investigative methodology, I found it a little difficult to grasp at first (a little dry, as science details can sometimes be), yet ultimately leading toward a hope of historical consciousness. Gaddis lists I think 6 examples with a detailed description of various ways and comparisons, and examples of historical hard science methods of investigation and its seeming evidence gathering (he calls general particularization through "continuities" of which the "new science" takes general ideas, findings of phenomenon that do not form patterns of history and manipulates them as evidence to a particular conclusion to historical methods. Historians attempt, as best they can, to connect through contingencies (and other methods) that is, through investigation and actual evidence (s) finding patterns that extend over time, though sometimes both are needed). I enjoyed in his last chapter his brief summary of these methods, using the cover of the book, a man, from his back, facing fog covered mountains and a camera pulling away from a deserted island of a vast continent to point to: simultaneous significance/insignificance, detachment/engagement, adventure and danger (historical landscaping) as polarities of what historical consciousness is and how it all points to an understanding of our future.

The Landscape of History is based on the series of lectures presented by John Lewis Gaddis during his Eastman Visiting Professorship at Oxford University. In them, he presents his thoughts on how and why historians pursue their profession.ScopeThe historian is a traveler in time and space with the freedom to (1) select the specific times and places, (2) simultaneously examine events that were originally separated in time and/or space, and (3) adjust the scale of his research from the micro to the macro in time, space, and events.History as Cartography?The historian creates a map, a representation of history, much as a cartographer creates a map that represents a portion of the earth's surface. Neither representation can capture all the detail of the original. Each must focus on a subset of the original chosen to illustrate specific features.History as Science?History can be thought of as a form of remote sensing. It employs thought experiments similar to those in such non-experimental sciences as geology, astronomy and evolutionary biology. These sciences, like history, are not replicable. Perhaps they are a form of history.History as Social Science?The social sciences (economics, sociology, some might include psychology) are intently focused these days on developing predictive models and identifying independent variables. Physics-envy, Gaddis calls it. The trouble is that there really are no independent variables. The Fed can change interest rates, but they do that in response to inflation. Inflation depends on the growth of the money supply which, in turn, responds to changes in interest rates. So, where is the independent variable? Rather than taking the reductionist approach of the social sciences, historians take an ecological approach, viewing events as part of an interacting system. Their goal is to understand what happened in the past, why and how it was significant, but not to predict the future.Narrative versus ModelsHistorians present their results in the form of narratives rather than models, and, as a result, their work is accessible to a much wider audience.Biography is a particularly difficult form of history. To be successful, the biographer must see the world and history through the eyes and mind of his subject and chronicle not only what the subject did but why. But then, having mind-melded with the subject, the biographer must break the bond in order to provide an objective assessment of the subject.The historian develops a representation of history, with the passage of time, may become the perceived historical reality. This creates a special responsibility. Moral judgments are an integral part of writing history. There is a currently popular "post-modern" urge among some academics to write purely factually, non-judgmentally, but how can one not judge Hitler, Lenin and Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, or bin Laden? The difficulty is to judge in a manner that convinces both professional historians and non-professionals.As a leading historian of the Cold War, Gaddis confronted one problem most historians experience only in their nightmares: The subjects of his research (many of whom were or are still alive) could and did confront him and challenge his narratives. Perhaps he envies the medievalists who are only confronted by Banquo's ghost.ConclusionsGaddis ends on an optimistic note: The sources of oppression are lodged in time and are not independent of time. We can escape then. But that is not to say that new sources will not arise.Historians' purpose is to help define the optimal balance within ourselves and within society between oppression and liberation. Here oppression and liberation are not limited to the conflict between the individual and society or government. They include conflicts within ourselves. Gaddis makes the interesting point that we need balance between oppression and liberation, not the elimination of oppression and maximization of liberation. Some (mild) forms of oppression are essential to stimulate growth, to interact constructively with society, to cope with life. The goal is to achieve an optimal balance in order to grow, to mature, to understand ourselves in relation to society.Reviewer's CommentsThe Landscape of History was both interesting and fun to read. Gaddis has retained much of the flavor of his original lecture series: The conversational tone and injections of subtle humor. I've read and reviewed several of his other books. I think this one gave me some insights into his methodology and work that I didn't get from his major works. I particularly enjoyed his comments on biography and will keep them in mind as I read his biography of George Kennan and contrast it with Kennan's autobiography.

John Lewis Gaddis' The Landscape of History is a scholarly yet very approachable work that successfully attempts to pick up the mantel of the famous scholars of historiography, specifically Marc Bloch and E. H. Carr. Gaddis' purpose is to encourage students and historians not only to reexamine the theories of Bloch and Carr in a more modern light, but also scrutinize the methodology that historians use, and more often than not, recoil from making explicit. Gaddis, in a veiled manner does refute some of the assumptions of postmodernism, primarily the extremist view that historians are unable to make conclusions about the past. Gaddis is content with inundating his work with metaphors, some of which span chapters to relate and clarify complex ideas and arguments to the reader since he claims that "we need all the help we can get" (pg 128). Gaddis, masterfully using this powerful tool, arrives at a concept of historical consciousness which he argues helps to establish human identity. In the course of this argument Gaddis explains how historians "achieve [this] state" (pg 129) through their manipulations of time and space, the mechanisms of structure and progress, and causation, contingency, and counterfactuals. He claims that the methodology that emerges, although long since said to be closer to the realm of the social science, actually uses methods and techniques more similar to paleontology, geology, and evolutionary biology since both require thought experiments.One of Gaddis' achievements is his ability to convey complicated ideas in a crisp, persuasive, and well-supported fashion. His primary tool is the use of extended metaphors, the most important being the painting The Wanderer above a Sea of Fog by Caspar David Friedrich, comparisons to sciences such as paleontology, and the length of Britain's coastline. Gaddis' exploration of metaphor of The Wanderer above a Sea of Fog spans his carefully unfolding arguments from beginning to end and each subsequent interpretation is added to by the next, providing a vast framework. These metaphors provide a point of reference for the reader and a visual embodiment of Gaddis' arguments. It encourages active participation by the reader in the argument and the layered interpretation exemplifies the complexity of his arguments and the complexities the historian faces in general.Gaddis argues that people cannot apply the `scientific method' to history, since historical events have already happened the causes cannot be proven with a physical experiment. But not all sciences use physical experimentation either. Paleography examines the remains and postulates from fossils that are millions of years ago. History and many sciences "start [s] with surviving structures;" the geologist studies an ancient formation, the historian his sources (pg 41). The conclusions are proven by thought experiments; however, the deductions made must be "tethered to and disciplined by their sources." Gaddis does not clearly state if history is a science, but declares that the "distinction would lie along the line separating actual replicability... from the virtual replicability that's associated with thought experiments" (pg 43). He is not skirting the issue for much it to be gained "by comparing what they do to what happens in other fields," namely, to illustrate facets of the historian's own methodology. This answer relates back to Gaddis' purpose, to argue that historians need to make their methodological approaches clear for "methodological innocence leads to methodological vulnerability" especially from the extremist critiques of the postmodernist (pg 51). Just as metaphors cannot convey the complexity in its entirety yet yield important benefits, comparisons to science allows the historian to examine their methodological methods.A critic of The Landscape of History probably would argue that the well-read student or historian already puts into practice, sometimes without knowing it, most of Gaddis' conclusions about methodology. However, Gaddis' purpose is not to belabor the obvious but rather to argue that historians need to make "their methods more explicit" (pg XI). This book rather, makes a point to examine these unconscious workings that once pointed out to us are often obvious. Like many historians and students Gaddis' admits that he also has questioned the benefit of history, a study that he has devoted his life to, and partially because of his unease he decided to write this book to reestablish in his own mind the importance of history (pg x). He concludes with the following powerful statements of the purpose of history which his metaphors slowly revealed: "by breathing life into whatever remains from another time... we thereby assure it a kind of permanence" (pg 140), the study "helps establish human identity" (pg 147), and by "learning about the past liberates the learner from oppressions earlier constructions of the past have imposed upon them" (pg 146). The most remarkable part of the book, and unfortunately the briefest, occurs on the last few pages where Gaddis argues that the "single most important thing any historian has to do.... is to teach" (pg 149). Gaddis' The Landscape of History is a fascinating and illuminating read for both the student and the historian.

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past PDF
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past EPub
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past Doc
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past iBooks
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past rtf
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past Mobipocket
The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past Kindle

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past PDF

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past PDF

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past PDF

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past PDF